Back to the Homepage
german version

An easy guide to build yourself a PC
Hardwaretests: Testresults and benchmarks
Viruses: Prophylaxis, identification, removal

All About PC - get in contact
All About PC - Impressum
Links

 Latest Reviews 

Click to read the review!
ABIT VP6
Click to read the review!
ASUS A7V133
Click to read the review!
EPOX 8KTA3+
Click to read the review!
DEEP OCEAN SCREEN SAVER

 ASUS CD-S500/A 
 Review 


Overview:
Introduction
Specifications
Read Rate, Pt. 1
Read Rate, Pt. 2
Error Correction
Conclusions
Author: S.Eppmann
 Reviews 
simyo - Weil einfach einfach einfach ist.


Error Correction

To test error correction, we intentionally made two scratches onto a CD.  Testing with this CD yielded the following results:

The drive slows down its rate when it encounters the scratches in order to read the data correctly, but aftward does not return to its maximum speed: First it checks to see if a higher speed is even possible, and then after a time gradually adjusts itself.

Access times

 

Random

1/3

Full

Original CD

91 ms

93 ms

143 ms

Green CD-R

92 ms

101 ms

154 ms

Blue CD-R

87 ms

93 ms

157 ms

CD-RW

114 ms

118 ms

255 ms

Here we see the same behavior that we saw with the transfer rates.  The drive does not differentiate between original CDs and CD-Rs, but with rewritten CD-RWs it decreases.  These scores are worse than what we usually see, keeping the drive at the lower end.

Log in

At 10 seconds, the log in time for original CDs and CD-Rs is quite good.  With rewritten CD-RWs, it only needs an extra split second to log in, which is even better.

Digital Audio Extraction (DAE )

I m Compared to most current CD burners, which achieve DAE rates of up to 25x, the ASUS CD-S500 seems kind of slow.  But compared to current CD-ROMs, these numbers are acceptable.

Manual & configuration

Packaged in a simple plastic bag, the drive comes with a CD and booklet that briefly describes the drive’s installation and features.  It also provides a brief troubleshooting section.  For more serious problems, a tech support telephone number is provided.

When using the drive, we encountered a great deal of noise: it sounded like a Saturn rocket getting ready to launch.  Fortunately, when the noises become too loud, one can decrease the maximum speed by pressing the Play/Skip button.

The left control key can be used to reduce the speed after a CD is inserted.  Depending upon the number of operations being performed, the maximum speed can be reduced to 40X, 32X, 24X, or 8X.  To resent the speed, eject the CD and reinserted.

One can see the results of this manual speed control from the following CDSpeed99 chart:

D IE Controlling the Speed manually turns out not to be so easy.  The drive does not register each change, but develops its own strategy.  A speed-controlling software would be more appropriate here.

 

Copyright All-About-PC. All rights reserved. 
All information on this Website is protected by All- About-PC. Reproduction and/or sale in any form without agreement of the publisher is forbidden. All information on this website has been thoroughly researched and as far as is possible has been verified by secondary sources, but we can not take responsibility for the content or for any damages incurred by using this information.